Before I started GrowthMentor, I made sure to be certain that I performed thorough growth audits on other marketplaces that were in completely different industries.

Tip: use waybackmachine to quickly audit the evolution of their product marketing, positioning, and UX treatments.

What I learned from auditing other successful two-sided marketplaces

The most successful all used SEO as growth loop.

Long-tail keyword-optimized pages are usually created programmatically and fueled by user engagement.

For example, when Taskrabbit launches in a new city, it instantly starts to rank for hundreds of competitive bottom-of-funnel longtail keywords.


Does this work?

Yes, this works very, very, well.

If your site has a decent domain authority you’ll be able to start seeing results within a couple of weeks.

Take a look at the Ahref report that shows the keyword madness.

Super bottom of funnel, highly specific = these pages convert.

Note: Hate link building? Then you’ll love this. If you have an established domain with a decent domain authority you should be able to rank without them. None of those TaskRabbit pages had even a single backlink!

Deciding to use SEO as a growth loop

If you’re bootstrapped and have a lot more time than money, choosing SEO as a primary growth strategy is a solid choice.

When building a scale-out SEO strategy for a marketplace, you have to choose:

  • Will you create the landing pages programmatically?
  • Will you create the landing pages manually?

Our development budget was already capped out as it was dealing with product, so we couldn’t go the programmatic route. We’d MVP this SEO strategy by creating the initial batch of around 100 pages by hand.

Tip: You can create dozens of new SEO optimized pages per week at very little cost if you document the process and train a small team of 2-3 VA’s to help with the project.

Keyword targeting

This was the /* keyword targeting strategy across all pages.

+ <keyword> + expert | e.g. 

We chose the url to follow this syntax “keyword-expert” vs. “keyword-mentor” since the searches with expert in the name had a much higher volume and competitiveness.

The gamble was that we’d naturally rank for the mentor derivative because the domain is already giving strong signals of relevance.

Leveraging User-Generated Content (UGC)

The best marketplaces are extremely good at collecting UGC and then repurposing it to drive their scale-out landing pages.

Our UGC strategy was to get the mentors to elaborate on their skill strengths and toolkit strengths on their profiles.

We’d then manually copy/paste that content into the new scale-out landing pages.


Results so far

So far we’ve got around 1,500 clicks in the last 6 months from all of these pages.

While it’s not a huge amount of traffic, the clicks had strong bottom of funnel intent which led to a few dozen conversions. Considering these are all high-intent keywords, we could have expected to pay at least $3 CPC for each of those clicks if we were playing the Adwords route, that would have cost us $4,500 in paid traffic.

What I love about Ahrefs is that you can see when your pages start to rank for certain keywords well in advance of any click-based evidence in Google Analytics. It starts measuring at position 100, but then again, so does Google Search Console. And that’s completely free 😉

Thoughts on backlinks

I mentioned at the beginning of the post how Taskrabbit was ranking for high-intent keywords with zero backlinks.

But if you’re like us, and don’t have super-strong domain authority, you probably won’t be that lucky.

Case in point: The #1 most successful page is the social media marketing mentor page, which coincidentally is the only one of these +100 pages that has a high DR do-follow backlink pointing to it from a relevant website.


Opportunity for Topic Clustering

The master plan is to use the landing pages as the pillars and interlink relevant blog posts together to create a hub and spoke model as seen below.

For example:

  • Hub Page:
  • Spoke Page:
  • Spoke Page:
  • Spoke Page:

If business booms and we can afford it, we’d love to add 2-3 content marketers to our growth team and increase our content production velocity.


If you’ve got a marketplace or a website that could benefit from a scale-out SEO strategy, start now!

Even if you can’t create the pages programmatically, you can hack the process by putting them together by hand for starts using a CMS.

Yes, it’s time-consuming, but with a proper procedure, you can delegate much of the grunt work to virtual assistants and then come back to give the on-site SEO a comb-over.

Hope this was interesting, any questions leave a comment below.

Growth Mentors

Looking for a strategy like this for your site?

Bounce ideas around with high level Growth Mentors and come up with the perfect growth strategy for you.
Learn more